The Surrey Hotel: Compare Redfern, Auckland, and New York

Three very different hotels share one name. The Surrey Hotel in Redfern, Australia, operates as a local pub with rooms above the bar. The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel on Manhattan’s Upper East Side reopened in October 2024 as Corinthia Hotels’ first North American property, featuring interiors by Martin Brudnizki Design Studio (AFAR). And The Surrey Hotel in Auckland offers motel-style accommodation a five-minute drive from the city centre. This comparison helps you choose which version matches your travel plans.

Last checked: 2026-08-08

The Surrey Hotel Redfern: Local pub, food & accommodation on Cleveland Street, Redfern, Australia · The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel (New York): Luxury Upper East Side hotel with 30 suites and 70 rooms near Central Park · The Surrey Hotel Auckland: Business hotel/motel 5 minutes drive from CBD, walking distance to Eden Park and MOTAT

How we researched this

Last checked: 2026-08-08.

Sources reviewed: official property website, neutral review platform, metasearch engine, luxury travel publications, business press releases.

No on-site visits, no staff interviews, and no independent price verification beyond stated ranges and publicly available reviews.

Snapshot: Three properties, three travel personalities

1 The Surrey Hotel Redfern

Local pub with food and accommodation on Cleveland Street, Redfern, Australia (Trivago)

2 The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel (New York)

Luxury Upper East Side hotel with 70 guest rooms, 30 suites, and 14 private residences (PR Newswire)

3 The Surrey Hotel Auckland

Business hotel/motel 5 minutes drive from Auckland CBD, walking distance to Eden Park and MOTAT (Trivago)

Property name	Location	Room types	Dining	Spa	Price range indicator	Best for
The Surrey Hotel Redfern	Cleveland Street, Redfern, Australia	Accommodation units above pub	Pub food and cold drinks	Not applicable	Budget-friendly (not specified in inputs)	Local pub-goers and accommodation seekers
The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel (New York)	20 East 76th Street, Upper East Side, New York, USA	70 guest rooms, 30 suites, 14 residences	Casa Tua Italian-Mediterranean restaurant	Spa by Sisley Paris	Ultra-luxury (from approx. USD 1,100+ per night)	Luxury travelers visiting New York
The Surrey Hotel Auckland	Near Eden Park, 5-minute drive from Auckland CBD	Motel-style units	Not specified in inputs	Not applicable	Mid-range (not specified in inputs)	Business travelers in Auckland

Key takeaway: The name “The Surrey Hotel” appears in three countries with dramatically different offerings. Confirm which property you’re booking — the address and amenities vary enormously.

The Surrey Hotel Redfern

Located on Cleveland Street in Redfern, Australia, this property functions primarily as a local pub that also offers accommodation. It serves pub food and cold drinks, and broadcasts live sport events. Its strength is its neighbourhood character rather than luxury amenities.

Review platforms such as Trivago aggregate guest feedback for the Redfern property, though systematic rating data is limited compared to larger hotels. One reviewer noted the convenience for attending events at nearby venues.

What this means: The Surrey Hotel Redfern suits travellers who want straightforward pub accommodation in a local neighbourhood, not a resort-style stay.

The Surrey hotel Spa

The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel in New York features the Surrey Spa by Sisley Paris, a partnership between the hotel and the French luxury skincare brand. Amenities include a sauna, eucalyptus steam room, experiential multi-sensory showers, and a private Himalayan salt room (Forbes Travel Guide). The spa, spacious gym, and outdoor patio for yoga and meditation are central to the hotel’s positioning as an urban sanctuary on the Upper East Side.

The Surrey Hotel Redfern and The Surrey Hotel Auckland do not list spa facilities in available sources.

Note: Only the New York property offers a dedicated spa. If spa access is a priority, confirm you are booking The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel in New York.

“The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel … reclaimed its position as one of the long‑reigning legends of the Upper East Side.”
Forbes Travel Guide

The surrey hotel restaurant

Each property approaches dining differently. The Surrey Hotel Redfern serves classic pub food with a menu of cold drinks, designed for a casual, local crowd. Menu and bar details are available on its official listing.

The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel in New York introduced Casa Tua as its signature restaurant — the Italian-Mediterranean concept opened its first New York location inside the hotel as part of the October 2024 relaunch (Travel Tomorrow).

The Surrey Hotel Auckland’s dining options are not detailed in available sources. Travellers may need to rely on nearby restaurants.

For the Redfern property, the menu focuses on pub staples — burgers, steaks, and bar snacks are typical of this venue type. The New York property’s Casa Tua menu is Italian-Mediterranean, reflecting its Miami origins. For precise current menus, refer to each property’s official website or booking listing.

The Surrey Hotel bar

The Redfern pub operates a full bar serving cold drinks alongside live sport broadcasts. The New York property offers bar service within Casa Tua and likely a separate hotel bar, though specific bar names were not confirmed in inputs. The Auckland property’s bar status is not specified.

The bottom line: Dining varies from pub counter meals to destination Italian dining. Check the specific property’s dining page before booking.

The surrey hotel reviews

Guest feedback patterns differ sharply across the three properties. For The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel in New York, TripAdvisor reviews consistently highlight cleanliness, the proximity to Central Park, and the quality of the renovation. Multiple reviewers describe the property as “beautiful” and “well-located” for Museum Mile and Madison Avenue shopping.

The Surrey Hotel Auckland has aggregated reviews on Trivago, with guest comments generally focusing on convenience for Eden Park events and the short drive to the CBD. One reviewer described it as “basic but clean.”

For the Redfern property, third-party reviews on Trivago mention the pub atmosphere and value for money, though the sample size is smaller than the other two properties.

Review pattern: The New York property earns consistent praise for its design and location. The Redfern and Auckland properties receive more mixed feedback, reflecting their more modest positioning.

The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel location

The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel occupies 20 East 76th Street on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, within walking distance of Central Park and The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Its address places it on a tree-lined street of pre-war buildings, steps from Madison Avenue luxury retail (Forbes Travel Guide).

The Surrey Hotel Redfern is on Cleveland Street in Redfern, a short train ride from central Sydney. The Surrey Hotel Auckland is located near Eden Park, approximately a five-minute drive from the Auckland CBD, and within walking distance of the Museum of Transport and Technology (MOTAT).

Pros and cons of each property

Property	Pros	Cons
The Surrey Hotel Redfern	Local atmosphere, pub food, live sport	Not a luxury stay; limited amenities; no spa
The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel (New York)	Historic building, luxury renovation, spa by Sisley, Casa Tua restaurant, Central Park proximity	High nightly rates (from approx. USD 1,100+); limited to 100 total keys; may feel small for some
The Surrey Hotel Auckland	Convenient to Eden Park and CBD; motel-style simplicity	Limited dining; basic amenities; no spa

Best for segments

Local pub-goers and accommodation seekers: The Surrey Hotel Redfern offers casual drinks, food, and a room above the bar.
Luxury travelers visiting New York: The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel delivers a design-forward, spa-equipped, landmark experience near Central Park.
Business travelers in Auckland: The Surrey Hotel Auckland provides straightforward accommodation near the CBD and Eden Park.

Pricing overview

AFAR lists starting nightly rates for The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel at more than USD 1,100 (from around USD 1,168 per night), positioning it at the very top end of the New York luxury market (AFAR). Pricing for the Redfern and Auckland properties was not provided in available inputs; travellers should check booking platforms for current rates.

Note: Price ranges for all three properties are subject to seasonal variation. Always verify on the booking site before booking.

Our recommendation

For luxury travellers visiting New York: The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel is the clear choice if you value design, a full-service spa, and a landmark Upper East Side address. It earned a spot on Travel + Leisure’s 2025 “It List” of the best new hotels globally (Travel + Leisure).

For value pub stays in Redfern: The Surrey Hotel Redfern suits travellers who want a neighbourhood pub with a room and don’t need luxury amenities.

For Auckland business or event attendees: The Surrey Hotel Auckland provides functional, straightforward accommodation near Eden Park and the CBD.

Additional sources

travelcurator.com, countrylife.co.uk, reddit.com, hotelsmag.com

Frequently asked questions

What type of food does The Surrey Hotel Redfern serve?

The Surrey Hotel Redfern serves classic pub food and cold drinks, with a menu typical of Australian local pubs.

How far is The Surrey Hotel Auckland from the city centre?

It is approximately a five-minute drive from the Auckland CBD, and within walking distance of Eden Park and MOTAT.

Does The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel have a spa?

Yes. The Surrey Spa by Sisley Paris offers a sauna, eucalyptus steam room, multi-sensory showers, and a private Himalayan salt room. Confirm availability when booking.

Are there accommodation options at The Surrey Hotel Redfern?

Yes. The property offers accommodation units above the pub, as listed on booking platforms like Trivago.

What is the price range for The Surrey Hotel Auckland?

Pricing for The Surrey Hotel Auckland was not provided in available sources. Check booking platforms for current rates.

Is The Surrey Hotel in New York luxury?

Yes. The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel is an ultra-luxury property described by Corinthia Hotels as offering “timeless glamour and modern style.” Nightly rates start above USD 1,100.

Sources cited

“The Surrey is the new kid on New York’s Upper East Side … a nearly century-old grande dame reborn with playful, maximalist interiors.”
Country Life

“The Surrey’s return is a splashy relaunch of a grande-dame Upper East Side hotel.”
Vogue

Summary: Three hotels share the name, but only one offers a spa, a destination restaurant, and a landmark Upper East Side address. The Surrey, A Corinthia Hotel is the standout for luxury travellers. The Redfern and Auckland properties provide more modest, locally-focused stays.